Marines vs army reddit. Soldiers also do not actually get treated that bad.

Marines vs army reddit I wanted to do navy first. Understand the distinct histories, values, and requirements of the Marines and Army, and which path may be right for you. Even the navy falls under it. 99. Jul 16, 2024 · Army is 22 weeks of infantry OSUT and Marines is 13 weeks of boot camp plus 14 weeks of infantry school. I am a very hands on, active, on the ground woman. Don't ignore the recruiting methods used by Army v/s Marines. . Lots of people love the Marines and lots of people hate the Army--so obviously figure out what is best for you! But the Army's size and variety is a strong item in the "pro" column, so to put the Marines above the Army, you need to figure out reasons that outweigh that plus. Currently the Army, Navy, and Airforce are trying to talk me into their specific branch. "I am sorry," says Major Terrence Washington. (Bigger then USMC and more funding) If you want to be America’s mostly highly trained infantry officer,be a devil dog, and will most likely get out after you’re first contact, go USMC. Once you are in a job, you are basically set in that position until you either pass away or retire. With the Army, you're stuck in your contract, whether you commissioned or not and stay enlisted for the entire contract. former active-duty 11B here. This subreddit is for questions about the British Armed Forces, experiences (plenty of sandbags to sit on for war stories), and anything else. Even then, your chances are very slim. If you want to do any sort of civil engineering stuff I would recommend Navy, Air Force, or Army over Marines. The army doesn’t offer group pt to the poolees. Army, they bought Harriers from the Royal Navy, and they are a department within the Navy. The Army, Navy, Air Force, Marines, and Coast Guard are branches of the US Military. I find more interest in researching the Army than the Marines. When I was in the Marine Corps, I always thought soldiers were undisciplined, fat and lazy. This is a common "grass is greener" idea. Military: All the forces a country uses to establish power internationally. Specify Army, Navy, etc. You have to be a tad crazy to be a Marine, keeps you level headed through the BS. You go to basic, then WOCS, then onto flight school with maybe a month or two of prep courses in between. Swimming, Shooting, Drill. Even much simpler, cheaper, and easier to make weapons from the 1970s and surplus shit would be way better than anything that was available in ww2. Army units were taking territory in Iraq during the invasion at the same time Marines were doing it. The marines and army are both combat forces, they will both be deployed to combat zones, including to battle insurrectionists. I’ve even seen Staff Sergeants in the Army assigned as team leaders, or maybe a squad leader. I was thinking Army and Marines would best fit me but I would like some outside help/information of what would be the best. There is a 10 year ADSO now after flight school, VS the Marines have an 8 year ADSO. But you'll get more mileage out of the job if that's what you're interested in. I’m wondering how the role of an Infantry Officer in the Army differs from a Royal Marines Officer? I’ve heard that Royal Marines Officer training is more focused on turning you into a Marine whereas Army Officer training is specifically about turning you into an Officer and a leader. If you want to stay in the military longer then the first contact and have more options in training & opportunities, go Army. 100 guardsmen isn't even a fair fight. The issue with the Army is that half of your co workers are felons or soon to be felons. He said the marine corps is for the complete military experience. The Army with all components is over a million Soldiers. Overall about 22 regular Army divisions served in the Pacific. Yeah he’s right. 3 mile run vs 2 miles. The US has the largest marine corps by number of active soldiers. The Marine Corps offers that kind of stuff, the Army will give you a better chance of promotions, schools, utilizing college benefits, etc. Got a someone in itb right now who was a e-4 in the army and transferred to the marines. AF doesn't currently require DLAB if asvab is high enough. They are similar but very different. Walter Thompson, the Marine Corps’ ad agency. If someone is “in the army” who knows what they do. Well the Marine Corps reserve is all the toxinsness of the Marine Corps incore minus deployments. In practice: Army is typically used as larger force groups on the ground level (e. The military is restricted from performing Law Enforcement due to Posse Comitatus Act, except for the Coast Guard. I assume you mean Marine Raiders vs Recon. And the Army has helicopters and some small planes, but legally can’t have its own air force. For reference I scored a 93 on my ASVAB, 99 on the DLAB (I had intention of doing linguist. Sign the fuck up and join the Corp The KIA rate for the Marine Corps and Army for both active and total force numbers is much higher than their actual percentages (Which makes sense considering the ground mission for the two services) but the Marines have a higher relative casualty pretty much any way you look at it. Possible chance of deployment around the world or to Antarctica! In the Marine Corps, there is a big emphasis on small unit leaders. But if you young and single you can have a lot of fun in the army but it's much harder to do 20 years. One slogan that a Marine coined during the span of my research, though, is “once a Marine, always a Marine. The Army are the dudes who come in and take over areas after the Marines clear them out, but the Army still sees a fairly high amount of gunfights. 5 space marines will mow them down with incredible efficiency. Then again, the Army is so much bigger. Once you complete Marine Corps basic training later in your career if you need to switch branches you do not have to repeat basic training. At first I wanted to go AF, but after thinking. A sub for anyone to ask questions about the military. I worked with several female Marines on a joint AF/Marine/Navy fighter and they loved the Marines, but liked working on an AF base due to better facilities. You can leave your car unlocked on AF bases, you can’t on Army bases. And the army can be as weird as the Corps is for field days, but for huge over the top morning PT sessions insanely early. The IJA’s force at that battle was far more numerous, but the Soviets has a lot more artillery, armor and air support, and they were a lot better at using those assets in a coordinated manner. Hazing (smoking), making people stay until 7 for no reason. Army is land based warfare, navy is water based, Air Force is air based, and marines are for maritime fighting. The Marines could do it but it is debatable on how likely they are to succeed. May 7, 2024 · For those who transitioned from the Marines to the Army, how did this change affect your sense of pride? Did you find yoursrlf prouder of your service in the Marines, the Army, or both, or did pride not significantly factor into your decision? Nov 21, 2024 · Marine Corps treats you like garbage while Army does a much better job preventing illness or injury. u/Schaftenheimen has previously answered Why was the United States Marine Corps such a small military branch before 1941?. I’m sure u get that with the army infantry but if u are trying to decide between the army and the marines I mean cmon. Apparently there were over 3 million soldiers on each side and several thousand artillery, aircraft, and tanks. The guard are great but it miss the Esprit de corps in the Marines, that make the toxic part bearable. 9% of the time, the only Marines that will even geta glimmer of hope of going to Ranger School will be the Reconnaissance Marines. Soldiers will identify as soldiers, but will more so identify with the specific unit they served, such as the 82nd, or 10th mountain. (Which is a bit contradicting, since I am asking in r/army about army AND Marines, but I find the Army reddit is a bit more civilized. Discipline. In the Army, if you have a pulse and don’t give up you will make it through flight school. however after 2 combat deployments to somalia and bosnia (yes I'm that old), i can find this img very amusing. You may find the below links helpful: Head To Head Comparison of the Military Branches. So who is the "worst" or may I say the best at hazing? Army Rangers or Marine Infantry? They bought old and used M-16's off of the U. In some countries, marines are part of the army. The Army had more of a presence in the war, as being a larger branch they fought in all 4 Corps of the country, so you could choose any number of the army division that were deployed and see a big variation in the experience. The Army treated them better but the quality of training didn't seem as well. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Coming from a marine go army infantry you will be guaranteed the job unlike marines they can give you an infantry contract you got to boot camp graduate and get fucked over and put in a pog mos. Eye to eye, the Marines and Praetorians take each other's measure. Hey all, so i’m looking to join the infantry, and i cant choose between Marines or Army, Army seems good because they have airborne while Marines youd have to go recon for that, and i’m not sure id make it. Without a declared war that would make this a Law Enforcement action, as it currently is. What exactly an army does is dependent upon the country. In the US, the Marines remained attached to the Navy for a very long time, as they were the infantry sub-unit to the Navy in the same sense the Navy was the waterborne sub-unit of the Army for most of the US's military history. I can go to the different recruiters and ask, but their answers are often bias. In the Army, the squad leader position usually goes to an E-6 and team leader E-5. ***Your post must be a question; chat posts are not allowed. There's no question and it's an utter mismatch. As far as espirit de corps, I think marines identify as marines, and is a source of their pride. You’ll be a janitor regardless. Marines are taught history which instills pride. Army recruiting focuses on benefits and career opportunities and a sprinkle of adventure. "The Few, The Proud" is a short and sweet (sounds a lot cooler than "Army Strong"), the commercials are over-the-top and will give just about any teenage guy interested in joining the military a War-Boner and their Dress Blue's are probably the cleanest, most pristine thing ever. But the ranks of 2ndLt to Captain takes 4 years at the very least. It can be hard to get a "Seabee" (CB/Construction Battalion) rating in the Navy just because of the manning situation right now. Marines can also be stationed on ships. If you can't get into the military for whatever reason atleast you tried. The US infantry won't pose any threat at all. Ask this exact same question about the US Army and US Marines and you’ll get just as confusing answers. As for Army vs Marines, you're going to get different answers depending on people's experiences with both branches. ***Please use a clear title for your question… Marine Corps has more discipline and esprit de corp in general, but you will see similar levels of fitness, training, discipline, and skill between a Marine unit and an Army airborne unit. You have less freedom in marines than army and also army gives you more chances for schools such as airborne ranger sniper jungle etc. Enlisting in the Marines with the eventual goal of enlisting in the Rangers is, once again, asinine. There’s many combat roles in each branch, but the Army and Marines are definitely the best bet for seeing actual combat. Another thing to consider is Air Force Special Warfare. TACP’s and CCT’s work with different branches all the time. Otherwise we'll assume you're American. Army is 22 weeks of infantry OSUT and Marines is 13 weeks of boot camp plus 14 weeks of infantry school. ) This is coming from several guys I served with in the Marines, who served in the Army as well. ***Please use a clear title for your question: clear titles get clear answers. What made me interested in the marines instead of the army was the difficulty levels. Oh boy. true. He holds his hands open. S. Hell, even SSGTs are considered “junior NCOs” in the Army. China has the largest army by number of active soldiers. "On behalf of the United States and the U. I want to join the marines but I’m not sure if I’m fit enough I’m 5’8 and 183 pounds I know no matter what branch I do want to do infantry for the marines either machine gunner or anti tank missleman and just basic infantry for the army my family thinks I wouldn’t be good in the marines because I’ve always been in their opinion too nice and expected me to be like my dad and go into I'm currently at the point of finally getting back in the military. Tank and armor vehicle movement) with levels of support. When it comes to intelligence disciplines, my favorite is counterintelligence, HUMINT, and GEOINT. well. Too low for navy. We’re just tougher and everyone wants to go to war here. That college experience is where you act like an idiot and hang on to that high school former glory. And some of the army barracks are just as bad the Marine ones. Yes, the Air Force has moslty less physical jobs. Once you go to Ranger school, you are a Ranger forever. Today, things make sense. which is fine btw. The Army throws you into AIT if you fail OCS. I was also in during war time and got deployed. ***"The military" is vague. If they are in the Marines, they probably are infantry, which universally are regarded as dumb, but a less significant portion of other forces. in my Force Recon platoon we had only 3 guys out of 24 that were Ranger qual'd. When I joined the natty guard, it just confirmed I was right… However! The entire guard is getting a mass influx of prior service Marines that people are starting to call the army national guard the “Marine Corps retirement home” Soldiers also do not actually get treated that bad. Army's premier light infantry unit, with specialized skills that enable the Regiment to perform a variety of missions. The moment you hit the fleet, you’re already facing great pressure to take over team leader positions. You can do the Marines and get chosen and not get through Marine OCS and walk to the Army and do their OCS. All you have to do is look back at the invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq. I want my college paid for but I want to feel like I earned it. Marines think they are the best and they act like it. Jan 9, 2025 · Compare the US Marine Corps and US Army: discover the differences in mission, training, and culture. The 75th Ranger Regiment is the U. As far as being a female in the military the USMC will treat you better than the Army (several female friends that joined the Army and Navy and wished they hadn’t). I originally wanted to join the Marines because the advertising made them look dope. 5 space marines vs. It's only 4 years, might as well do something you'll be proud of. But, the Air Force also has much less military career opportunities as a whole. Just like once you become a Marine, you are a Marine forever. And I've heard the phrase "Jarhead of the Army" when describing Rangers. (b) The Marine Corps shall develop, in coordination with the Army and the Air Force, those phases of amphibious operations that pertain to the tactics, technique, and equipment used by landing forces. 383 votes, 314 comments. Also, ignore the fact the the US has the Air Force as its own air force, but so does the US Navy and US Marines. There are army units as bad as the Corps units, if not worse. The culture of the Army, especially aviation is MUCH more relaxed. Army vs Royal Marines, Advice I want to join the military as an office and have been considering both the army and the Royal Marines I was wondering if anyone could give some extra back ground on how the royal marine office training course works and what it entails. Marines is a bit longer overall but I don’t think there’s much infantry training during the 13 week boot camp. Because of that it much harder to that same level brotherhood. The Marines had way better training but treated you like crap and they were in shitty units. Basically, I'm a prior service Marine reservist, a Lance Corporal, and due to some pretty strange circumstances, I have the option to go full “The Few, the Proud” slogan actually came out in the 1970s, coined by J. I’ve been set on the army rangers for a while but was recently approached by a USMC recruiter. A subreddit for all of those in, interested in or have served in the British Armed Forces of any branch. ” I wanted to get a actual un-bias view on what the differences are between the Army & the Marines. Marines are not explorers they are soldiers, a marine will never be sent to explore a world, though they have been sent to escort scientists on board UNSC ships. ) Okay, obviously I know that the 75th is a completely different animal than the Marine Corps, I just needed an attention grabber. Same shit, different areas of operation. The Marines seem to value their choice of a branch, even if their job never sees them near what would be considered “combat”. The entire Marine Corps is less than 200k. Qual for it the army). Hi everyone, I (19M) am joining the military as soon as I can. promotion system - yeah army/marines really did good one this one. The marines on the other hand have most of that logistical/support taken care of by the navy (or army). Coast Guard - out to sea for a few months, in port for a few months. Army mostly rotates into Eastern Europe, like Poland or a rotation to Korea. First question is does the army have the same camaraderie as the USMC. China, for instance, calls its entire military the People's Liberation Army. In modern times, Marines and Army will both be the main force. Include your country if you're not asking about the US military. Then I talked to my math teacher who was in the Army. Go military when your 18 so when you get out if you do you'll be 21 or 22. I believe the marine corps is great for giving a sense of accomplishment. you've never served. (The Department of War ran the Army; the Department of the Navy was a secondary Cabinet position. But Army Navy and Air Force have to complete Marine basic to join the Marines. That, or filling the blank spots with busy-work (cleaning, inventorying, vehicle maintenance, armsroom inspections I recommend you join the military first if you can. We talked and I’ve come to the conclusion that I’m going to enlist in the Marines as infantry mos, get some tougher training off the bat compared to Army and then if I’m still set on Army ranger I will move into the Army after my service with the USMC. So basically, the Navy is the Marine Corp's big brother because without the Navy the Marines would have no combat medics (Corpsmen) and the Marine Corps is much smaller than the army. You either commission or they release you. Opportunities that interest me: Marine Corps is the toughest branch to join. Don't waste time in college. g. There are certain requirement you have to reach to be looked at on a board for promotion to Captain and Major. bigger branch = more opportunities. Army and Marine units fought together on Guadalcanal. Army seems very political though and Marines seems more laid back although with hard work. Navy: has ships and fights on the water (or from the air, based on water like an aircraft carrier) Air Force: Fights with planes and bombs and stuff. Five years Air Force and 12 years Army (so far). Soldiers also do not actually get treated that bad. (There are exceptions). They seem to value “tradition” more, from the words they say to the uniforms they wear you can see they try to differentiate themselves from the Army. -Marines don't have to maintain vehicles as much as the army does, so if you don't want to pmcs strikers all day go Marines or an Army light unit. 26 votes, 11 comments. Each branch can be very different and saying "the military" isn't helpful. ASVAB Explained Exactly this. The more salient difference I think is deployments and where you go. Possible chance of deployment around the world or to Antarctica! The Kwantung Army’s 1939 defeat at Kholkin Gol (vs the Soviets) is a great example of the kinds of problems the IJA would have versus the US Marines. In the Marine Corps, there is a big emphasis on small unit leaders. Besides direct action raids, these include: Airfield seizure, special reconnaissance, personnel recovery, clandestine insertion, and site exploitation. I dont regret the army but I tell people to join the airforce because 20 years is much more doable the army marines or navy. Learn about the unique roles of each branch, including combat, peacekeeping, and humanitarian efforts. TACP’s are almost always embedded with Army or Marine units (more the Army than Marines, though). Marine grunts are also known for hazing new guys. Coast guard is good option too if you like being by the water I don't know much on military history, but I can tell you that the Marine Corps are the masters of PR. Despite Marines being vaunted for their marksmanship, the Army produces the best shooters in the entire military and world. The only weapon the infantry might posses that might do some damage to a space marine is an AT4, but the chances of them even landing a hit on a space marine is low. So now you have the Coast Guard vs the cartels, which is currently what we have going on. Top 10 Things You Should Know Before You Join the Military. Then I realized how shitty the amenities are, and the Army offered more opportunities for me. When I joined the natty guard, it just confirmed I was right… However! The entire guard is getting a mass influx of prior service Marines that people are starting to call the army national guard the “Marine Corps retirement home” 57K subscribers in the Militaryfaq community. I’m/was leaning toward the army heavily but now but after going to a marine corps group pt I loved the camaraderie. " His gaze is level and honest. So the marines are heavily combat focused. While in the Marine Corps, those jobs usually go to Lance corporals and Corporals. The Army tends to have a unit pride, but the Rangers are something else entirely. But to get to the rank of Major in the Marine Corps your looking at at least 6-8 years. 10/10 in my book Cons: Work life - no one does their job you're always doing other tasks, going to the field for 3 months, or doing a detail that doesn't even slightly involve your mos. The whole, once a marine always a marine thing. i’m worried about advice that people have given to me about career prospects after the marines and what i can gain from the marines vs what i can gain from the army. [4][5] The However, these additional duties may not detract from or interfere with the operations for which the Marine Corps is primarily organized. The Corps is the worlds biggest frat, it's far, far, far more of a brotherhood than being in the Army is. Lastly, is culture differences. And the US Army has They are patriots, and they are cool tacticians. Army needs to capitalize on the fact that they have a ton of diverse career fields (especially compared to Marines) and that they have the badass aspects -Having a Ranger Regiment is an excellent idea for the big army, and I wish the Marine Corps could somehow find a way to better duplicate the existence and practices of 75thRR for our betterment. The Marines have invested decades of effort into structuring an image and a brand recognition that appeals to young men (mostly) who want a challenge. And the liberation of the Philippines was primarily an Army operation, mainly because the Philippines with their large islands were much better suited to the Army than the Marines. u/when_ducks_attack has previously explained the role of the Marines in Europe (scroll down for the follow-up answers, this answer is less than six months old) Army/Marines - on base in the States, or abroad (think Europe/Korea for Army and Japan/Australia (new!) for Marines). Marine Corps, I apologize deeply for the misunderstanding. I met with the marine corps, navy, and army. From an army perspective, I think it’s because Marines tend to have pride in the fact that they are Marines. Garrison life: morning PT, a "9-5" daily grind that revolves around preparing to go to a field training event, being at the field training, or having just gotten back and doing "recovery" from field training (cleaning and inventorying all the things). Marines you'll either rotate to Japan or do a MEU that'll see you in dozens of countries. I wanted something that was going to challenge me further than anything has ever done before. wow. The Marines are terrible - and I will never ever ever recommend the Marines to anyone. They are both SoF elements. So the 75th Ranger Regiment is known for hazing their new guys. cbk eaflby veab myfe cmwsru yij kskqw bfociko ptq rdqh ckih zqjcf hqxnhi zpbx pko